Jump to content

We Can Debate All We Want


Recommended Posts

QUOTE (aldonb1 @ Oct 3 2007, 08:55 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
nice statement cymptom.

As to the *smokers cough* i personally believe this is due to hookahs producing a different composition of "tar" while compared to cigarettes. This is due to the shisha baked and releasing vapors instead of the tobacco being burned in a combustion reaction. Personally I am really interested in the composition of hookah tar, no study has been done on it as far as I can tell. I'm actually applying for a grant from school ($1500) to conduct research on the tar. Plan on doing standard stuff: composition, volume, density, etc. I plan on comparing the composition to known carcenogenes. (Luckly I get access to our schools bad ass mass spec). I hope to do this for: Al Amir, Al Waha, Nakhla, Tangiers, Afzal. Using quicklights (3k), japs (Starlights or Easy-Lights), and natural finger coals (Nour finger). I'll submit my proposal up here whenever I finish it and have my mentor look it over =)... sorry for getting a bit off topic.

time to go smoke some tangiers mint mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.... tongue.gif


This is exactly what I wanted to know for months! Finally someone has picked up on this and Good luck to you in researching this.. Post ya results on this forum wink.gif
Link to comment
Share on other sites

yeah I apply for the grant at the end of this semester, if anyone has any ideas just PM me.

amnite, brought up a good point to me that I should include SOEX herbal shisha into the research. I'm working this in now. =)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

People who say that smoking hookah is healthier or safer are just trying to make themselves and possibly others feel better about their actions. These people will get defensive and angry if you try to despute this fact.
Anything you put into your lungs that isn't supposed to be there, has the potential to cause negative effects.

People just want justifications in their actions. Everything and anything related to smoking is frowned upon. They say that it's better because it's not an acutal cig. I attribute this attitude to the whatthefxup and anti smoking campaigns that are crammed down everyones throats. So many people are craving approval / justification, that they will say and do anything to get that approval. No matter is the information spewing from their mouths, is wrong.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

But I think I'd choose hookah over cigarettes since I wouldn't be addicted to nicotine, coughing out tar, spend more money, and breathe poorly?(i can't think of that term where you lose your breath easily) amongst others that I don't know of or think of. Smoking a hookah might share some of these symptoms but not to that extent.

If we were all to bet which act (hookah or cigarettes) would shorten a lifespan more, considering an average hookah smoker and an average cigarette smoker (pretend we have all this data), my money is on cigarettes. I'll even start taking bets with 2:1 odds when we get more research and data in the distant future.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (anathema @ Oct 5 2007, 02:45 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
i can't think of that term where you lose your breath easily)


Shortwindedness, a nicer way of saying you completely lack endurance. Something I've had LONG before cigars/cigs/mah baby hookahs. I blame laziness entirely wink.gif
Link to comment
Share on other sites

agreed I have reworked the list a bit... due to budget restraints ... sigh... Gelman Inline Polycarbonate Filter holder, filter paper type A/E , and MALDI mass spec costs is going to raping me.

Nakhla
Al Fakher
Tangiers
Starbuzz
SOEX Herbal (I know no one actually likes this crap but its will be interesting to see the NFDPM produced from it)
Layalina

Which does everyone feel is more popular, Layalina or Havana.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (aldonb1 @ Oct 8 2007, 12:12 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
agreed I have reworked the list a bit... due to budget restraints ... sigh... Gelman Inline Polycarbonate Filter holder, filter paper type A/E , and MALDI mass spec costs is going to raping me.

Nakhla
Al Fakher
Tangiers
Starbuzz
SOEX Herbal (I know no one actually likes this crap but its will be interesting to see the NFDPM produced from it)
Layalina

Which does everyone feel is more popular, Layalina or Havana.


Layalina

The list is good because it covers a good variety of brands
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tar is not tar in the sense that most people believe. It is actually an acronym for Total Aerosol Residue. It is a particulate that is developed by the combustion of the tobacco. Tar composition in cigarettes and hookah may possibly be very different and I am also very interested in seeing it under closer scrutiny
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (kornkitten42 @ Oct 5 2007, 03:10 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
People who say that smoking hookah is healthier or safer are just trying to make themselves and possibly others feel better about their actions. These people will get defensive and angry if you try to despute this fact.
Anything you put into your lungs that isn't supposed to be there, has the potential to cause negative effects.

People just want justifications in their actions. Everything and anything related to smoking is frowned upon. They say that it's better because it's not an acutal cig. I attribute this attitude to the whatthefxup and anti smoking campaigns that are crammed down everyones throats. So many people are craving approval / justification, that they will say and do anything to get that approval. No matter is the information spewing from their mouths, is wrong.


i agree. my friend jsut started smoking hookah, we've been going ot the bar every week, sometimes twice a week.  last night he says to me "this isn't that bad for you, is it?"  i immediately thought of this thread and i just replied "smoking is smoking, dude.  its marginally better than cigs, but thats because we dont smoke as often."  he just said "oh... fuck it." and took a big draw.

its a lifestyle choice...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (SafeSearchOff @ Oct 9 2007, 04:01 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
i agree. my friend jsut started smoking hookah, we've been going ot the bar every week, sometimes twice a week. last night he says to me "this isn't that bad for you, is it?" i immediately thought of this thread and i just replied "smoking is smoking, dude. its marginally better than cigs, but thats because we dont smoke as often." he just said "oh... fuck it." and took a big draw.

its a lifestyle choice...



We all gonna die and turn to dust one day either by smoking or getting hit by a bus...might as well enjoy what life has to offer biggrin.gif

-Ben
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...