Jump to content

Putting the electric theory to rest.


Recommended Posts

After extensive experimentation with an actual "electric tobacco heater" and the same heater torn apart and modified for optimum performance, I have concluded that using electricity to smoke off of instead of coals simply doesnt work as well as coals.
I'd hoped for awhile that it would be a reasonable method to smoke (and save $$$ on coals) alas, my results were unsatisfactory.
After ajusting heat and millimeters at a time I could get an optimum smoke quantity from the electric heater, the smoke quality just wasnt there.
So for anyone curious and willing to invest in this method, dont - it simply doesnt work.
My theory on its failure is that it just toasts the tobacco to death (toaster heating elements were tried, and proved most successful ),but still sucked.
Its kinda like getting those famous coal walker guys to perform a balancing act across a red hot wire, suspended 5 stories up, with the same predictable drastic results displayed on the unfortunate sessions test subject.
Coals are the way to go, period.
I am smoking with them now, and the heater has been exiled to the far corners of my hallway closet, never to be gazed upon again.
A sad day for cheapskate experimental science for smoking pwnage indeed :-.
 
P.S.
It ****ed me up pretty bad too, rofl.
 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey now, just because you tinkered with it doesn't mean someone else
won't be succesful in the future. You gave a valiant effort, nothing to
be ashamed of.

Oh, I'll take that tobacco heater off your hands, especially if you don't plan on using it anymore :)

Where did you get your aparatus from, online hookah store?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

i'm kicking myself right now, i was looking at a charcoal lighter last night and now i can't find the link for you. but it was pretty cool, it had a little head dial and everything. You put your natural coals in the little metal cup thing and set your heat and it says it will get you natural coals hookah ready in 3 - 4 minutes.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually Mr.Guy, what Glavin was using was first marketed to be an an electric tobacco heater- so that you would justbly put it on your bowl, and use no coals to smoke.When everyone came back and said it was damn near impossible to smoke with, they started calling them *COAL* lighters.Hookah-shisha.com carries them
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Like I said, the engineering says it won't work. Prove control theory wrong, if you can! Its good to test things out, make sure we're not all missing something...if it could work, it would be great.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Funny, hookah shisha is where i originally got it years ago. I'm glad they changed the name and redefined its functions, as this thing can get coals cooked fully in seconds.
I know the electric "toasting" way wont work for a fact now, but what id really like to know is why wont it?
I became physically unable to smoke it after a while because. i developed a burning in the back of my throat (distinctive from any coal use in the past.) and after 10 mins i got a pain in my ears right where they connect to my head, it was weird stuff. other symptoms included a greater shortness of breath then usual and a slightly nauseated feeling.
All for science though
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm sure tangier would be able to exlpain it.
just a hit in the dark, but maybe the reaction that happens to get the smoke from the shisha involves the CO or CO2 given of from coals when they burn (coals being carbon and all)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ah...the control system issue, the response-delay time for the electric heater is too slow (underdamped). Like your furnace, it turns on-off several minutes after it decides that it needs to. Of course when you're smoking hookah, in that time your bowl has gone out or scorched hard. 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the post, Glavin.  I've always wondered whether or not the electrical heaters worked well.  Now I don't have to waste any money on one.
 
Secondly, what does "pwnage" mean?  I've seen this word a bunch of times on the internet and could never figure it out. 
 
Marcus
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...